Rachel Recchia and Blake Moynes know what it feels like to have their happily ever afters shatter in the final hour. Moynes ended his engagement to Katie Thurston in 2021. Meanwhile, former Bachelorette star Recchia called off her 2022 engagement to Tino Franco following his confession of infidelity. Now, with the debut of Bachelor in Paradise Season 9, both have stepped onto the sandy branches of Mexico with healed hearts and a renewed hopefulness about finding love.  Photo: ABC/Craig Sjodin